1. The court held that the Massachusetts statute discriminated against out-of-state wineries ?oby...

Question

1. The court held that the Massachusetts statute discriminated against out-of-state wineries ?oby design?? (intentionally). How can a court determine legislative intent?
2. Suppose that most ?osmall?? wineries, as defined by the 2006 Massachusetts law, were located out of state. How could the law be discriminatory in that situation?

The ratification of the Twenty-first Amendment ended Prohibition and gave states substantial control over the regulation of alcoholic beverages. Most states, including Massachusetts, then imposed a three-tier system to control the sale of alcoholic beverages within their territories. The hallmark of the three-tier system is a rigid, tightly regulated separation between producers, wholesalers, and retailers of alcoholic beverages. Producers can ordinarily sell alcoholic beverages only to licensed in-state wholesalers. Wholesalers then must obtain licenses to sell to retailers. Retailers, which include stores, taverns, restaurants, and bars, must in turn obtain licenses to sell to consumers or to serve alcohol on their premises. Recently, as to wine, Massachusetts has adjusted the separation between these three tiers

David · Accepted Answer

Courts regularly look to authoritative procedures (translations of meeting minutes, hearings, floor talks about, and so forth) to decide authoritative goal. For this situation, 
for instance, the court refered to remarks amid floor talk about made by a few Massachusetts administrators about the new winery-directing law. One representative 
recognized that "we are truly as yet giving an innate favorable position in a roundabout way to the neighborhood wineries." Another congressperson asked that apple and 
other natural product wines not be incorporated in the gallonage top of 30,000 in light of the fact that something else,

1. The court held that the Massachusetts statute discriminated against out-of-state wineries ?oby design?? (intentionally). How can a court determine legislative intent? 2. Suppose that most ?osmall??...

Solution

Answer To This Question Is Available To Download

Related Questions & Answers

Submit New Assignment