5/5/2021 Dante And The Perils Of Pity | The American Conservative
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/drehe
dante-perils-of-pity/#:~:text=The reason for the infernal,time%2C is the inappropriate response. 1/17
Cybersecurity that crushes Malware Buy…
JANUARY 14, 2014 | 1:08 PM
(HTTPS:
WWW.THEAMERICANCONSERVATIVE.COM/DREHER/DANTE-PERILS-OF-
PITY/#DISQUS_THREAD)
ROD DREHER (HTTPS:
WWW.THEAMERICANCONSERVATIVE.COM/AUTHOR/ROD-DREHER/)
(HTTPS:
WWW.FACEBOOK.COM/SHARER/SHARER.PHP?
TTPS%3A%2F%2FWWW.THEAMERICANCONSERVATIVE.COM%2FDREHER%2FDANTE-
PERILS-OF-PITY%2F)
(HTTPS:
TWITTER.COM/INTENT/TWEET/?TEXT=DANTE AND THE PERILS OF PITY -
&URL=HTTPS%3A%2F%2FWWW.THEAMERICANCONSERVATIVE.COM%2FDREHER%2FDANTE-
PERILS-OF-PITY%2F)
VE.COM%2FDREHER%2FDANTE-PERILS-OF-PITY%2F&TITLE=DANTE%20AND%20THE%20PERILS%2
20SPACE%20ABOUT%20THE%20FRENCH%20PROVERB%2C%20%26%238220%3BTO%20UNDERST
%20HAVE%20PERFECT%20FORGIVENESS%20%26%238230%3B%20BUT%20ON%20THE%20OTHER
PERILS-OF-PITY%2F%22%20CLASS%3D%22READ-MORE%22%3EREAD%20MORE%3C%2FA%3E
(MAILTO:?
0AND%20THE%20PERILS%20OF%20PITY&BODY=HTTPS%3A%2F%2FWWW.THEAMERICANCONSER
PERILS-OF-PITY%2F)
Dante And The Perils Of Pity
(https:
www.theamericanconservative.com)
DONATE (HT TPS:
THEAMERICANCONSERVATIVE .COM/DONATE/)
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. to find out more, read our Privacy Policy
(https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy/).
ACCEPT
(http
https:
cat.va.us.criteo.com/delivery/ck.php?cppv=3&cpp=rAq0y7-u5mI5BQ8pyjxbtat6IjQQrR6_m5hP-wxCfzT5tZOrcgSYL6W5eARr6kHBkOyOAxUwUou_lCUs1jW0ctuk0rnYkAq08t1Yfr2siVFtVpc1L29UrVb4GN_bcVZfYgKFqJRdvwT-MLlz82jx4EAD96DsrG9TOPRBd3rcVCbz--2ShHpky-mYHFcx59yeKC1YUoYylYo441PfbIOiLlmJ39aGxTFWMNWHa_MsphWaf3-8D6I3sCF9bAqc7Yoem1cmo-intlM2Pl6Ktnmc3bmFPJ2ecyF51p3l--A5A5VWjnx8lqESAU9AdSV2FgMkue8jE9WpvcvJBvkTb0IMTBqzNoGZWiDgNX9HnzRbT74xbTYcg91JZxsumnTTbEwGbWZoS7H6YPYpu4qTGUXvSb4ze0QKeBUjzu3cMcPslbSH76jzeqnaL8arJFU_bAMtmMtkhVX5Jwu9GGFzyW1zTpepisU&maxdest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.malwarebytes.com%2Flp%2Fsem%2Fen%2F%3Futm_source%3Dcriteo%26utm_medium%3Dcpc%26utm_campaign%3DAdaptive%26utm_term%3DB2C%26utm_content%3Dmulti-device-091020
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/autho
od-drehe
https:
www.facebook.com/share
sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theamericanconservative.com%2Fdreher%2Fdante-perils-of-pity%2F
https:
twitter.com/intent/tweet/?text=Dante%20And%20The%20Perils%20Of%20Pity%20-%20&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theamericanconservative.com%2Fdreher%2Fdante-perils-of-pity%2F
https:
www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theamericanconservative.com%2Fdreher%2Fdante-perils-of-pity%2F&title=Dante%20And%20The%20Perils%20Of%20Pity%20-%20&source=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theamericanconservative.com%2Fdreher%2Fdante-perils-of-pity%2F&summary=In%20the%20past%2C%20I%20have%20written%20in%20this%20space%20about%20the%20French%20prove
%2C%20%26%238220%3BTo%20understand%20all%20is%20to%20forgive%20all.%26%238221%3B%20It%20is%20a%20double-edged%20sword.%20On%20the%20one%20hand%2C%20it%20tells%20us%20that%20to%20have%20perfect%20understanding%20is%20to%20have%20perfect%20forgiveness%20%26%238230%3B%20but%20on%20the%20other%20hand%2C%20it%20tells%26hellip%3B%20%3Ca%20href%3D%22https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theamericanconservative.com%2Fdreher%2Fdante-perils-of-pity%2F%22%20class%3D%22read-more%22%3ERead%20More%3C%2Fa%3E
mailto:?subject=Dante%20And%20The%20Perils%20Of%20Pity&body=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theamericanconservative.com%2Fdreher%2Fdante-perils-of-pity%2F
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com
https:
theamericanconservative.com/donate
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy
javascript:void(0);
http:
info.yahoo.com/privacy/us/yahoo
elevantads.html
https:
youradchoices.com
5/5/2021 Dante And The Perils Of Pity | The American Conservative
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/drehe
dante-perils-of-pity/#:~:text=The reason for the infernal,time%2C is the inappropriate response. 2/17
I
n the past, I have written in this space about the French prove
, “To understand all is to forgive all.” It is a
double-edged sword. On the one hand, it tells us that to have perfect understanding is to have perfect
forgiveness … but on the other hand, it tells us that to give oneself over to total sympathy is to lose sight of
the reality of evil.
This is one of the hardest lessons the pilgrim Dante learns as he marches through Hell with Virgil. The
eason for the infernal leg of Dante’s pilgrimage is to restore his awareness of the reality of sin as an objective
eality. In Canto V, Dante swoons with pity for the condemned Francesca and Paolo, but that, as he will learn in
time, is the inappropriate response. Virgil instructs Dante that he must learn not to pity the damned. Virgil is not
teaching Dante to be hard-hearted; rather, he is teaching Dante to rightly order his emotions, because his own
salvation depends on it.
It’s a subtle but crucial point. What Virgil (and Dante the poet) is saying is that for the damned, there is no hope.
Their eternal fate is sealed. Nothing can be done about it. They have chosen their own fate. To pity them in that
state is to doubt God’s justice. The damned, in fact, do not contend that they do not belong in Hell; they only
deny their own personal responsibility for their fate. If Dante (the pilgrim) is to understand what sin means, he
must resist pity. The damned often try to win Dante’s sympathy, a strategy that will not help them (they are
eyond help), but can only seduce and potentially destroy Dante.
Consider the case of Brunetto Latini, Dante’s former teacher. Latini, a real-life figure (as most of those Dante
meets along the way were), was Dante’s old teacher. The pilgrim is shocked to see his beloved master, who
was like a father to him, and who was the parent of his (Dante’s) writing career, suffering in Hell. Latini is in the
circle of Sodomites, but his sexual behavior never comes up in conversation with Dante, which is respectful,
even affectionate. Brunetto tells his old student not to lose heart, for he is surely bound for fame:
And he [said] to me: ‘By following your sta
you cannot fail to reach a glorious port,
if I saw clearly in the happy life.
Latini, a famous writer in his own right, again counsels his pupil, telling him that he is bound for glory if only he
will believe in himself. The pilgrim, deeply moved by these words, responds:
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. to find out more, read our Privacy Policy
(https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy/).
ACCEPT
(http
https:
cat.va.us.criteo.com/delivery/ck.php?cppv=3&cpp=4fdT67-u5mI5BQ8pyjxbtat6IjQRJR2lXqNOXaCdwOnqv8MmEB4kgRQM9QpIqFFJ_szVnjMlg1JGegMjIr9M6U4W64pyhKywqKdYJPy4Vk4hlB7zWGvKPLWuXv2MH1xYlzGI-rmHiE_frVW9xZ0T56a_0bVeYJuWV87OKwO58iw4U0CWh4lCIr_kCfOTcX_yuq3tZeKiXykl9pKgrHgZig6k4ooAkwIfFx60-y0l2hk08Vc079qIZy0EZeg5Tifj8BM5tMUmEz-rVNXucpvwuHcnYNm4yikptF7PMilz51AhUtlcHy6-zt87QH6i2rh0zRl0-eqzV4o43CVGnPlUyRB5KODicnNG50eU1Reh34esaTZeaKYCn1dH7kHm5S4lRt-465JSYaL6LWatUIOOOuqky9KgngzcECTwnUysnYx9hMvJ7JrE13j5RjVa6qqBKFSd3EjwGlLhUZL46pLR35JdwwA&maxdest=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.malwarebytes.com%2Flp%2Fsem%2Fen%2F%3Futm_source%3Dcriteo%26utm_medium%3Dcpc%26utm_campaign%3DAdaptive%26utm_term%3DB2C%26utm_content%3Dmulti-device-091020
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy
javascript:void(0);
https:
youradchoices.com
5/5/2021 Dante And The Perils Of Pity | The American Conservative
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/drehe
dante-perils-of-pity/#:~:text=The reason for the infernal,time%2C is the inappropriate response. 3/17
‘If all my prayers were answered,’
I said to him, ‘You would not yet
Be banished from mankind.
‘For I remember well and now lament
the cherished, kind, paternal image of You
when, there in the world, from time to time,
‘You taught me how man makes himself immortal.
And how much gratitude I owe for that
My tongue, while I still live, must give report.
Dante is paying sincere homage to the man who taught him how to write, and who here, in Hell, is encouraging
Dante to believe in himself and in his own talent. The pilgrim even goes so far as to doubt God’s judgment; such
is his love and pity for Brunetto that he says he wouldn’t have put Brunetto in Hell.
But Brunetto is in Hell. God, who is all-just, cannot make mistakes. Where is the pilgrim’s mistake?
It lies both in his own pride, and in his filial piety toward his old master. Brunetto did, in fact, teach Dante how to
write well, which Dante characterizes as learning how to make himself immortal. The word is critical here. Fo
Brunetto, eternal life is fame; the writer, to achieve immortality, must write for the sake of fame. This orientation
has earned Brunetto a place in Hell. Why? Consider that Brunetto is condemned to spend eternity walking in a
scorched desert with fellow sodomites: an icon of sterility. What Dante the poet is telling the reader is that one’s
creative gift comes to nothing — is sterile, not fruitful — if it is devoted to promoting oneself.We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. to find out more, read our Privacy Policy
(https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy/).
ACCEPT
(http
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy
javascript:void(0);
https:
youradchoices.com
5/5/2021 Dante And The Perils Of Pity | The American Conservative
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/drehe
dante-perils-of-pity/#:~:text=The reason for the infernal,time%2C is the inappropriate response. 4/17
Follow your own star, Brunetto tells Dante. How many of us have been given the same advice, and would accept
it as normal and healthy? Believe in yourself. This is a seductive lie, the poet shows us. The wise artist will not
navigate by his own star, but by the stars set in the sky by God. To serve one’s own ego can only leave to
sterility and damnation. For an artist to be a fruitful creator, he must serve higher truths, realities beyond his
own self-interest. The greater the artist’s talent, the greater the temptation.
In this encounter, Brunetto tells his old student that if he had known how great Dante was going to be, he would
have promoted his student even more back on earth. That sounds generous, but the truth is, Brunetto’s real
game is promoting himself via Dante. He wants to ride on Dante’s coattails. As the Dante scholars Bill Cook and
Ron Herzman explain, Brunetto is like the college professor who enjoys seeing his student succeed, for the
sake of his own personal glory. The professor wants to get the phone call from Oprah, asking him to come on
TV and talk about his connection to the great man who was his student. What Dante the pilgrim can’t fully
appreciate at this stage in his journey is that Brunetto is a flatterer and a false counselor. To be clear, Brunetto is
not consciously trying to mislead Dante; if he were, he would have been in the circle of False Counselors
further down. But he really is misleading Dante, and Dante, in his vanity and in his pity, is opening himself up to
sin.
Again, this is a subtle point, but a hugely important one. The journey through Hell is important to restore Dante’s
understanding of how sin works, and how we fall victim to it. Remember, for Dante, all sin comes from a
perversion of Love. In this case, Dante’s love for his old teacher, and his filial respect for his master’s authority,
stand to trip Dante up.
Not everyone in Hell is pitiable, at least not to Dante, but those the pilgrim does pity are those whose sins the
pilgrim can see himself committing: sins of lust, and the sin of pride leading to misuse of his creative gift.
Reflecting on this, I can easily see myself falling victim to the Brunetto fallacy. If I were to write a personal
Inferno, I wouldn’t have had myself swoon from pity over a damned lustful person, but from a sinner damned fo
Gluttony. My weakness would have been to have had pity for a great gourmand, or perhaps a great chef, who
gave himself over to the disordered love for good food and wine. Food and wine really are good things — as is
Human Love, as is Creative Art. But if they are em
aced in a disordered way, if we come to love them fo
themselves, and not as secondary to God, they can lead to our damnation.
Dante, man! Tolle, lege.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. to find out more, read our Privacy Policy
(https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy/).
ACCEPT
(http
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy
javascript:void(0);
https:
youradchoices.com
5/5/2021 Dante And The Perils Of Pity | The American Conservative
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/drehe
dante-perils-of-pity/#:~:text=The reason for the infernal,time%2C is the inappropriate response. 5/17
(https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/autho
od-
drehe
)
Rod Dreher is a senior editor at The American Conservative. A veteran of three decades of magazine and newspape
journalism, he has also written three New York Times bestsellers—Live Not By Lies, The Benedict Option, and The Little Way
of Ruthie Leming—as well as Crunchy Cons and How Dante Can Save Your Life. Dreher lives in Baton Rouge, La.
email (mailto: XXXXXXXXXX)
Sponsored Content
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Yes
No
Not sure
14,650 Votes
Do you approve of President Trump?
Promoted Content
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. to find out more, read our Privacy Policy
(https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy/).
ACCEPT
(http
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/autho
od-drehe
mailto:% XXXXXXXXXX
https:
lockerdome.com
oi
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/privacy-policy
javascript:void(0);
https:
youradchoices.com
5/5/2021 Dante And The Perils Of Pity | The American Conservative
https:
www.theamericanconservative.com/drehe
dante-perils-of-pity/#:~:text=The reason for the infernal,time%2C is the inappropriate response. 6/17
Recommended by
ALSO ON THEAMERICANCONSERVATIVE
2 days ago 22 comments
Project Artemis is a
eminder that NASA has
long spent tax-payer …
Social Justice in SpaceSocial Justice in Space
• a day ago 13 comments
A conversation outside a
pizza place with a young
woman whose family lost …
The AmericanThe American
ConservativeConservative
• 3 days ago 12
Why is a mem
Communist P
Britain’s