Please follow instructions has mentioned
BSc. Undergraduate Research Module NUR5021
Integrated Evidence-Based Professional Nursing Practice
September 2019 cohort
Summative Research Assessment
Students will critique a given research paper in accordance with the accompanying guidance on the requirements for their 3000-word assignment.
Each student is sent a copy of the paper to be critiqued.
The paper to be critiqued is:
Kennedy, M. and Burnett, E XXXXXXXXXXHand hygiene knowledge and attitudes: comparisons between student nurses. Journal of Infection Prevention. Nov XXXXXXXXXXVol XXXXXXXXXXNo. 6. pp XXXXXXXXXX
Students: please note that in Scotland undergraduate pre-registration nursing degrees are 4 years in length.
The 3000-word research assessment is in 2 sections.
Section 1 relates to 10 questions of a relevant Critical Appraisal Skills tool (CASP). The 10 questions are to be addressed sequentially in the assignment. Please do not state each question and then provide an answer, but put Q.1. and provide an answer to Q.1, and then proceed in this way with each successive question. Each answer to a numbered question should be a paragraph of around 200 words.
This will give a total of 2000 words.
In Section 1 should a question be asked about an aspect of research, which is not mentioned in the published paper, students are advised to consider the content of the tuition sessions they have received. Students should also look-up the aspect of research on which the question is based and provide an answer on what would have been expected in order to address the question. Any research aspects not appearing in the publication is probably due to the publisher’s word-count allowance, but as these aspects are part of the research process knowledge of them is readily available.
Section 2 has a 1000-word allowance. It is for the student to give an overall professional opinion of the paper. For example, a student could support or disagree with the methodology and methods that have been used in the paper and consider alternatives. The student is also asked to consider that if he/she were to conduct a study into the same topic would the same research paradigm be used, or a different research paradigm to that originally used? Please explain how the study would be designed and why.
Students are expected to use other references (those not cited or listed in the given research paper) in support of the points they wish to make in sections 1 and 2 of the assignment.
A reminder: please do not state each question and then provide an answer, but put Q.1. and provide an answer to Q.1, and then proceed in this way with each successive question. Each answer to a numbered question should be a paragraph of around 150 words.
Section 1 Questions:
1. Does this paper have any research aims? If so, please state these in your own words. Is this study of interest, and if so is there any group of people who would find this study of particular interest? Please give reasons for your answers.
2. What is the methodology used in this study? Is the methodology appropriate for the aim/s of the study? Please state the reason for your answer.
3. From a literature search the research authors stated possible reasons for non-compliance with a good hand hygiene technique. Explain these reasons in your own words
4. How were the students recruited into the study, and how was voluntary informed consent obtained?
5. What is meant by the WHO ‘5 moments for hand hygiene’? Explain these in your own words.
6. What data collection methods were used? Are these appropriate for the study? Briefly explain your answer.
7. Discuss the method/s used for data analysis. Are these appropriate to the study? Briefly explain your answer.
8. Explain what is meant by “descriptive statistics”.
9. Discuss how the data findings are presented. Are the data findings clear?
10. Do the research findings relate well to the title and to the stated aims of the study? Briefly explain your answer in relation to validity and reliability.
Section 2.
Write 1,000 words giving an overall professional judgement and opinion of the paper based on evidence-based practice and how this is underpinned by research.
Remember, for both sections 1 and 2 include external references as appropriate to support the points, or the line of argument being taken.
The submission date is Thursday 10th December 2020 by 12 noon via turnitin.
Only submit by the Nursing Programmes Submission in-box should any problems be encountered with turnitin.